Located in Hastings’ Cornwall Park and constructed in 1911, the King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain has historical significance as one of many structures around New Zealand built to commemorate that event. It is symbolic of New Zealand’s general enthusiasm for, and allegiance to, the Crown at that time. The drinking fountain has importance as an iconic central focus of Hastings’ oldest, and consistently popular, park. Named in 1901 for the Duke of Cornwall and York (1865-1936), later King George V, Cornwall Park is associated with the British royal family as well as the important early New Zealand ecclesiastical family, the Williamses, who donated the land. Although Hastings grew significantly in the last decades of the nineteenth century it had no recreational parks for citizens to use. This need was answered by James Nelson Williams (1837-1915) who donated a portion of his Frimley Estate. In 1901 it was gifted in honour of the Duke and Duchess’ New Zealand tour. This was the first royal visit in over 30 years and was a huge event nationally. A decade later, when the Duke ascended to the throne and the Duchess became Queen Mary, the Government subsidised buildings and structures all around the country in celebration. Fittingly, the Hastings Borough Council opted for a monument to be erected in Cornwall Park. The plaques on the monument commemorate the park’s creation, the coronation, and the Duke and Duchess of York’s 1927 tour. The fountain remains a key feature of the park, especially for generations of children for whom playing on the lions is an essential part of any visit to Cornwall Park. The monument’s design competition was won by the Hastings Borough Council draughtsman and assistant engineer, Victor Ernest Larcomb (1888-1961). Constructed in concrete, with some marble embellishments, this structure consists of a tall central column featuring the plaques, as well as four pedestals around the exterior of the octagonal base with drinking fountain bowls and fittings, topped by pairings of vases and lions. The monument shows Classical influences, prevalent in the period for this type of structure, and decorative flourishes such as Corinthian columns and moulded bunches of fruit and foliage.
Location
List Entry Information
Overview
Detailed List Entry
Status
Listed
List Entry Status
Historic Place Category 2
Access
Able to Visit
List Number
1078
Date Entered
5th May 2014
Date of Effect
5th May 2014
City/District Council
Hastings District
Region
Hawke's Bay Region
Extent of List Entry
Extent includes part of the land described as Lot 142 DP 1302 (RT HB68/128), Hawkes Bay Land District and the structure known as King George V Drinking Fountain thereon, as well as a 2 metre curtilage from the platform's edge in all directions. (Refer to map in Appendix 1 of the registration report for further information).
Legal description
Lot 142 DP 1302 (RT HB68/128), Hawkes Bay Land District
Location Description
Mahora is a suburb north of the Hastings central business district and is accessible when travelling [north]east off of Heretaunga Street West along Tomoana Road. Cornwall Park is approximately 900 metres away from that intersection, on the south side of the road. The King George V Drinking Fountain is approximately in the middle of the park, and the arterial footpath, which connects to the park’s main gates on Tomoana Road, is close by.
Status
Listed
List Entry Status
Historic Place Category 2
Access
Able to Visit
List Number
1078
Date Entered
5th May 2014
Date of Effect
5th May 2014
City/District Council
Hastings District
Region
Hawke's Bay Region
Extent of List Entry
Extent includes part of the land described as Lot 142 DP 1302 (RT HB68/128), Hawkes Bay Land District and the structure known as King George V Drinking Fountain thereon, as well as a 2 metre curtilage from the platform's edge in all directions. (Refer to map in Appendix 1 of the registration report for further information).
Legal description
Lot 142 DP 1302 (RT HB68/128), Hawkes Bay Land District
Location Description
Mahora is a suburb north of the Hastings central business district and is accessible when travelling [north]east off of Heretaunga Street West along Tomoana Road. Cornwall Park is approximately 900 metres away from that intersection, on the south side of the road. The King George V Drinking Fountain is approximately in the middle of the park, and the arterial footpath, which connects to the park’s main gates on Tomoana Road, is close by.
Cultural Significance
Social Significance or Value The King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain expressed Hastings’ respect and support for the royal family and in particular King George V and Queen Mary. Plaques on the monument detail the background to the creation of Cornwall Park, and the on-going ties to the family when the Duke and Duchess of York were received there in 1927. As the focal point of Cornwall Park, Hastings’ first, and a continually popular, park, the King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain is closely associated with local community leisure activities. In particular, it has a fond place in the childhood memories of generations of park visitors who have played on its lion features.
Historic Significance
Historical Significance or Value The King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain has historical value being constructed in celebration of the coronation, using a special government subsidy. It also commemorates the gifting of Cornwall Park as a result of the new king’s 1901 royal tour when he was the Duke of Cornwall and York. Cornwall Park and its King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain reflect local expressions of loyalty and enthusiasm for the British royal family, sentiments that were repeated all around New Zealand to mark the 1901 royal tour and the subsequent coronation of King George V. This monument also demonstrates the local contemporary expansion of public facilities motivated by Hastings’ rapid early twentieth century population growth. A key example of this was the gifting of Cornwall Park in 1901 by members of the important early New Zealand ecclesiastical family and prominent local landowners of the Frimley Estate, the Williams family. The addition of the King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain provided a further public facility while also engendering civic pride.
Physical Significance
Aesthetic Significance or Value The King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain has aesthetic significance as a central, iconic, and highly visible feature of Hasting’s Cornwall Park. The tempered Classical features and decorative elements soften the impact of this concrete structure and help it to sit comfortably within its park setting.
Detail Of Assessed Criteria
(a) The extent to which the place reflects important or representative aspects of New Zealand history As a British colony New Zealand has had close ties to the royal family and monarch, the head of state, since the mid nineteenth century. Especially in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, royal tours were greatly anticipated and commemorated by various events and the construction of public facilities. Hastings’ Cornwall Park and its King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain exemplify this, as does the subsequent royal reception there in 1927. (b) The association of the place with events, persons, or ideas of importance in New Zealand history Having been built in honour of the former Duke of Cornwall’s ascension to the British throne, in his namesake park, the King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain is also connected with this monarch and his earlier tour to New Zealand. A closer association with the family was created as a result of the public reception for the King’s son, the Duke of York, being held in Cornwall Park in 1927, later also commemorated on the King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain. The fountain is also closely associated with the important early New Zealand ecclesiastical family, the Williams family, who became significant local land owners from the 1860s, and set aside the land for Cornwall Park in 1898. (e) The community association with, or public esteem for the place The local community have had a close connection to this place since its inception because the decision to build a drinking fountain to celebrate King George V’s coronation was the result of public consultation. As the central feature of Hastings’ first, and continually popular, park, the King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain is well-known locally. There is a close community association with the monument because children are particularly drawn to its lions, and playing and being photographed on them has become a rite of passage. This aspect of the monument was celebrated in 2001 with a community photography exhibition. (h) The symbolic or commemorative value of the place The King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain symbolises the on-going close ties between New Zealand and the British monarchy. In particular, it is indicative of the strong public will in the early twentieth century to create lasting evidence of loyalty and esteem for the monarchy when key events occurred, such as royal tours and coronations. Both the creation of the park during King George V and Queen Mary’s 1901 tour when they were the Duke and Duchess of Cornwall, and their ascension to the throne, are commemorated by this monument, as is a 1927 visit by the Duke of York.
Construction Professional
Biography
Victor Larcomb’s father Ernest was a ‘highly respected civil engineer and architect’, and his son followed him into these professions. Victor left a draughtsman position in the Feilding Public Works Department District Engineer’s office in 1908 to work for an unspecified ‘leading Wellington architectural firm.’ It is unclear how long he stayed in Wellington before taking up a job in Hastings as the Borough Council’s draughtsman and assistant engineer. It was while there in 1911 that he won the design competition for the town’s King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain in Cornwall Park. A few years after the structure was erected Larcomb became a founding Associate Member of the New Zealand Society of Civil Engineers. By 1919 he was back in Wellington and had set up business as civil engineer and architect. He seems to have been based in Wellington from then on, and in the 1930s was serving on the Wellington District Free Ambulance and Wellington Employers’ Association Boards. Source: Registration report for King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain
Name
Victor Ernest Larcomb (1888-1961)
Type
Architect
Biography
No biography is currently available for this construction professional
Name
E & W Platt
Type
Builder
Construction Details
Start Year
1911
Type
Original Construction
Description
Marble plaques replaced
Start Year
2001
Type
Maintenance/repairs
Construction Materials
Concrete, granite, marble
Descended from the Takitimu canoe through Tamatea Arikinui’s grandson, Ngati Kahungunu ki Heretaunga is Hawke’s Bay’s predominant iwi. Ngati Kahungungu’s dominance began to be asserted around the sixteenth century, but Maori are first thought to have settled in the province about 1300. Heretaunga was rich in resources and Maori settlements were mostly around the coast or situated along the area’s numerous waterways. Hastings is located between two key rivers, the Ngaruroro and Tukituki, and their tributary streams. There are consequently many recorded archaeological sites indicating Maori settlement in the immediate vicinity, including pa, pits and terraces, and urupa. By the late 1850s Wairarapa’s European pastoralists were moving further north and the Government purchased large tracts of land from Ngati Kahungunu to meet this demand for land. Now one of Hawke’s Bay’s main cities, Hastings was established later than other main towns in the province. Thomas Tanner (1830-1918), a Central Hawke’s Bay runholder, and his consortium illegally leased a large portion of the Heretaunga Plains from Maori in the 1860s. The lease was formalised in 1867, and the entire block was purchased by Tanner’s syndicate, nicknamed the Apostles, in 1870 and divided among them. Although officially cleared of fraud, underhand methods and intimidation are known to have been employed if reluctance to sell was encountered. Within a few years Hastings had been laid out and the fledgling town was quickly given a boost when the railway went through in 1874. Soon key features such as the racecourse and showground were established and businesses blossomed, particularly those to do with meat and wool processing. For example, Tomoana freezing works was established in 1884. By the turn of the twentieth century fruit growers were important to the local economy too, and enterprises such as the Frimley Canning Factory opened, soon followed by cool storage facilities. With business came people and between 1901, when Cornwall Park was established, and 1911, when the King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain was built, the population of Hastings almost doubled. Therefore, civic amenities were increasingly being considered, such as larger municipal buildings and theatre, a public library, and recreational facilities. Cornwall Park was Hastings’ first park. Although not formally gifted to the town until 1901, James Nelson Williams (1837-1915), owner of Frimley Estate, had set aside the land for the park in 1898. While Victoria Square was public land in 1897 it was leased for crops and grazing until 1906. In contrast, top-dressing and planting had been undertaken at Cornwall Park, and a cycle track is known to have been established, by November 1905, soon followed by tennis courts, and cricket pitches. For decades it remained Hastings’ main sports ground and recreational park, and remains one of the city’s ‘premier parks,’ featuring many historic trees. James Williams was the cousin and brother-in-law of Archdeacon Samuel Williams (1822-1907). Both James’ father William (1800-1878), and Samuel’s father Henry Williams (1792-1867), were important missionaries and Henry translated the Treaty of Waitangi into Maori. Cornwall Park, formerly part of Frimley estate, was presented to the people of Hastings in 1901 by Samuel’s daughters: Anna Lydia Williams (1854-1938) and Lucy Frances Warren (1868-1925). Frimley was the result of Samuel securing James some of the Heretaunga Block as part of Tanner’s venture in 1864. From the 1870s James was said to be ‘a shareholder in and director of practically every scheme to advance the progress and welfare of the province.’ Later, the Williams family donated the remainder of Frimley to Hastings for parkland after the homestead was destroyed by fire in 1951. Cornwall Park was presented and named in honour of Prince George (1865-1936), at that time the Duke of Cornwall and York, who toured New Zealand that year along with the Duchess. This was a momentous occasion because no members of the royal family had visited since Prince Alfred (1844-1900) in 1869 and 1870. Coming only five months after the death of New Zealand’s first monarch, Queen Victoria, the 1901 tour was especially important to New Zealanders because it gave them a direct way of displaying their continued support for the monarchy and admiration for the late Queen, the Duke’s grandmother. There were many events to mark the tour including John Logan Campbell (1817-1912) donating a substantially larger piece of land in Auckland, also known as Cornwall Park. However, a difference was that that gift was acknowledged in person – Hastings not being on the royal couple’s itinerary. Ten years after the tour which cemented the Hastings land’s future as Cornwall Park, the drinking fountain was constructed to commemorate the Duke succeeding his father to the throne, becoming King George V. To mark the coronation the Government offered to grant a subsidy of up to £250 towards public buildings and structures. Conditions applied, such as no subsidy would be given on borrowed money and applications were due by Coronation Day, 22 June 1911. A public meeting was held in early June to decide the form of Hastings’ commemorative gesture. Ideas ‘ranged from the erection of a municipal theatre to the construction of a two-mile boulevard from Hastings to Havelock North. Ultimately it was decided to erect a drinking fountain in Cornwall Park.’ This seems to have been because it was both affordable and could be constructed in a timely fashion, as well as having a symbolic link to the new king because of its location. These kinds of meetings were happening all around New Zealand at the time because communities were keen to create ‘expressions of loyalty.’ The extent of interest in the scheme was underestimated by the Government, with the Minister of Internal Affairs noting in October that ‘…the applications had greatly exceeded the amount anticipated – it was really about double….’ Examples of what other communities built include the Waiau Coronation Library and Hall and the Warkworth Town Hall and the King George Hall in Bay View, Napier. Along with band rotundas and swimming baths like Queenstown’s Coronation Bath House, halls were among the most common form of commemorative structures because the grants were specifically targeted towards them. However, there were at least three other fountains constructed in public parks commemorating the coronation - in Hawera, Christchurch, and Temuka. It is unclear whether these were drinking or ornamental fountains, but they were funded by private donations. The Hastings drinking fountain received the government subsidy for half of the 212 pounds and 17 shillings construction cost. A design competition for the Cornwall Park structure was quickly organised, with the Borough Council’s draughtsman and assistant engineer, Victor Ernest Larcomb (1888-1961), being the successful entrant. Larcomb’s plans for the King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain date from August 1911. Built by E & W Platt of Wellington, the design included a tall central section, replete with moulded garlands and explanatory plaques. The perimeter pedestals each feature a drinking fountain. One pair of pedestals was topped with urns, while the other had lions modelled on the recently established Wellington Zoo’s famous attraction, King Dick. Further cementing ties to the family, King George’s son Prince Albert, the Duke of York (1895-1952), was welcomed to Hastings in Cornwall Park during his 1927 tour. He later became King George VI in 1936 after his elder brother’s abdication. The Duke and Duchess’ tour was more comprehensive than previous ones, because they ‘visited most of the larger North Island towns’ before continuing onto the South Island. A few years before the Duke and Duchess’ tour, Cornwall Park was described as: ‘less beautiful than the one in Auckland, but certainly a happy hunting ground for explorers of five and six years old…It isn’t a monotonous stretch of lawns and garden, but there are unexpected walks and arbours and glimpses between the trees, all of which make it a pleasant place….’ This pleasant place played a key role in Hastings’ first experience of royalty, hosting the Duke and Duchess there on 4 March 1927. It was reported that Hastings ‘made no secret of the fact that it expected the visitors, all the countryside appeared to have come to town to augment the local people, and not only [at] Cornwall…but the streets leading to it were all filled.’ On subsequent royal occasions the public reception was held elsewhere. For example the Duke of Gloucester’s welcome during the 1934-1935 tour was staged at Hastings Racecourse, which would have accommodated a larger crowd. It may also have been because Cornwall Park was being developed during this period, with the creation of its ponds and limestone bridges and seating. A few decades later the newly crowned Queen Elizabeth II was welcomed at the Civic Centre in early January 1954, but subsequently in 1963 she only made a ‘brief stop’ in the town. Other events hosted at Cornwall Park included the official welcome for the Governor General and his wife, Lord and Lady Bledisloe, in 1930. Lord Bledisloe returned to Cornwall Park the following year to lead a memorial service a few days after the Hawke’s Bay earthquake, expressing sympathy on behalf of the King. Cornwall Park, with the drinking fountain as its focal point, is still used for community events. For example, there is an annual International Cultures Day festival, and it is the home of the Cornwall Cricket Club. With three rest homes nearby the park is a popular place for elderly people to take a walk, and young families also frequent it regularly. In particular, playing and having photographs taken on the drinking fountain’s lions has been a rite of passage for children visiting the park, as well as some adults. Indeed, in 2001 an exhibition called ‘Laying it on the Lion’ was held at the Hawke’s Bay Exhibition Centre celebrating people’s personal photographs of interaction with the lions. One of the lions is a hero image on the Park’s interpretation signage and the entire structure is often referred to as the Lion Monument.
Current Description Located near the centre of the park, close to the edge of the cricket ground, the King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain is at least partially visible from most areas of the park. However, the density of some of the mature trees and other landscape features in the eastern quadrant do obstruct this view. Images indicate that nearby plantings began being established in the 1920s. At this time the monument stood out as the clear focal point of the rather austere park. The monument is now positioned amidst a grove of trees, all of which are at least several metres from the structure. Although no footpath leads directly to the monument, it is close to the arterial path leading from the Tomoana Road gates. Constructed in 1911, the main components of the drinking fountain are its octagonal stage with four pedestals, each topped with either lions or urns, around a central ornamental column. The layout is similar to, although an expanded version of, King Edward’s Coronation Memorial Fountain (circa 1902) in Palmerston North’s The Square, which Larcomb was probably familiar with having resided in the area. However, the central sections demonstrate starkly different influences – the Palmerston North example is clearly Gothic Revival inspired, while the columns and other decorative features of the King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain, such as the festooned fruit and foliage, are a Classical treatment more common at the time and stylistically akin to structures like the Honeyfield Drinking Fountain in New Plymouth or the Te Peeti Awe Awe Memorial, also in The Square, both constructed circa 1907. The King George V Coronation Drinking Fountain’s octagonal concrete pad has three steps leading up to the formerly functional, and the commemorative, elements of the structure. Perpendicular to each alternate side of the octagon are the concrete pedestals. Of these, the north and south pedestals are topped with decorative vase features, and the symmetrical nature of the structure is completed with concrete lions sitting on top of the remaining pair. Each of these pedestals has an outward facing basin and remnants of a metal tap, which used to form the structure’s utilitarian component. It is unclear when the drinking fountains stopped functioning. The pedestals with the lidded vases have a square footprint, whereas their couchant lion neighbours have rectangular bases. Both types of pedestal have rose coloured marble panels inset on each side. Representing strength, power and imperial dominance, lions are a traditional symbol of the British monarchy, so their inclusion would have seemed an obvious choice for Larcomb, much as it had a few years earlier for those constructing South African War memorials, as well as King George’s father’s coronation fountain in Palmerston North. The concept for the drinking fountain had the lions’ manes coloured to match the red granite lower columns of the structure’s central section, and the rest of each animal was a terracotta colour. It is unclear whether this was done initially but they appear to have been painted a terracotta colour in the early twenty-first century. The original plans also show the lids of the vase featuring a flame-like motif rather than the sphere at the apex. The original concept of moulded leaves fluting upwards to form the vase was incorporated though. The central section has a square base, with a polished red granite column at each corner, under the eaves of the main shaft. The columns have Corinthian capitals which are flanked by sets of four modillions (ornamental brackets). Several of the concrete capitals have sustained damage. For example, the top outer corner of the northwest capital has been chipped off, as has one of the southeast capital’s scrolls. Between the columns on each face of the base is a marble inset inscribed with commemorative details. By 2001 the original panels were weather worn and vandalised, and the marble originals were consequently replaced with white granite equivalents. The information on the respective panels is as follows: the east inscription notes that the structure was constructed in commemoration of the 1911 coronation of King George V and Queen Mary; the north panel documents the donation of Cornwall Park; the west plaque notes the mayor and councillors at the time the Drinking Fountain was constructed as well as the designer and builders; and the southern panel commemorates the Duke and Duchess of York’s 1927 visit to the park. The tall central part of structure is the decorative and commemorative focal point. This concrete main shaft is moulded at its base and then rises into an octagon. The concrete has been finished with incised lines to create the appearance of masonry. Into each side of this are recesses, similar to the base insets and those on the surrounding pedestals, with bunches of fruit and foliage adornments above. The shaft terminates with a further row of foliated decorative features. Above are dentils and then a cornice featuring egg and dart mouldings. This central section is completed with a dome from which a spherical finial ascends. The support for this is surrounded with mouldings.
Completion Date
4th April 2014
Report Written By
Karen Astwood
Information Sources
Boyd, 1984
Mary Boyd, City of the Plains, A History of Hastings, Wellington, 1984
Department of Internal Affairs
Department of Internal Affairs
Wright, 2001 (3)
Matthew Wright, Town and Country: The History of Hastings and District, Hastings, 2001.
Davies, 1989
Davies, Valerie, Royal Tourists; 120 years of royal visits to New Zealand, Auckland, Random House, 1989
Williams, 1953
Williams, C. H., New Zealand Journey, Royal Visit 1953-54, Wellington, Secretary of Internal Affairs, 1953
Report Written By
A fully referenced registration report is available on request from the Central Region Office of the NZHPT Please note that entry on the New Zealand Heritage List/Rarangi Korero identifies only the heritage values of the property concerned, and should not be construed as advice on the state of the property, or as a comment of its soundness or safety, including in regard to earthquake risk, safety in the event of fire, or insanitary conditions.
Current Usages
Uses: Civic Facilities
Specific Usage: Fountain
Uses: Commemoration
Specific Usage: Memorial - Particular person or group
Uses: Commemoration
Specific Usage: Monuments, memorial, site of particular event - other