Before the arrival of Maori from Taranaki in the 1820s, the Wellington area was populated primarily by people of Kurahaupo waka descent, including Ngai Tara, Rangitane, Muaupoko, Ngati Apa and Ngati Ira. The Waitangi Tribunal referred to these as ‘Whatonga-descent peoples’ since all claimed descent from Whatonga, an early Maori explorer, who named the harbour Te Whanganui a Tara, for his son Tara. The people from the Taranaki region were often given the common name of ‘Ngati Awa’ (and later Te Atiawa) by outsiders, but they comprised a number of tribes. These ‘incoming tribes’ included Ngati Toa (also known as Ngati Toa Rangatira), Ngati Rangatahi, Te Atiawa, Ngati Tama, Ngati Mutunga, Taranaki, and Ngati Ruanui.
By the 1820s, Europeans were arriving at Port Nicholson (as it came to be known, after John Nicholson, the Sydney harbourmaster). In May 1839 the New Zealand Company advertised in London 990 lots of Port Nicholson land for sale in a colonisation scheme. Each lot was to consist of 101 acres – comprising 100 rural acres and one urban acre – at a cost of £1 per acre. All 990 lots were sold by July 1839 and in August 1839 Colonel William Wakefield arrived and began negotiating with Maori to purchase land. The first immigrants began arriving in January 1840.
Cemetery
Eighteen acres of land were set aside for cemeteries by the New Zealand Company in Captain Mein Smith’s survey plan of Wellington of 1840, plus a small area to the south for Roman Catholic burials. The public reserves, including the cemetery, were ‘approved and appropriated’ when Governor Hobson visited Wellington in August 1841. Burials there began immediately after.
The area was simply called ‘cemetery’ without any sectarian divisions. However, Bishop Selwyn requested a piece of land within the cemetery that could be consecrated for Church of England burials. The land was divided proportional to the number of adherents among them; the Church of England receiving about half. Surveyor S C Brees drew up a map in 1843 showing the divisions, and the Church of England enclosed its portion with a fence at its own cost. However, as the Church of England’s portion already contained the graves of people of other faiths, this caused considerable resentment which took some years to diminish. In 1849 the dispute was largely settled. Bishop Selwyn agreed to a 30 year period in which relatives of those ‘non conformists’ already buried in Church of England land could be interred in the Anglican cemetery, provided their names were listed in a schedule to the legal agreement. The land was divided into five sections, two of which were set aside for the Church of England, two for a general public cemetery, and one small section for the Jewish community. Early graves were surrounded by white picket fences and were quite visible in the generally tree-less environment – such fences being the cheapest and easiest markers available to relatives, and necessary due to wandering animals. It was many years before trees provided some shelter.
The Church of England finally consecrated its cemetery on 31 December 1855. The Church’s sexton dug graves and maintained the cemetery, but his duties were combined with the role of verger of St Paul’s, which was built in the Government Reserve in 1844, later replaced by the present Old St Paul’s in Mulgrave Street in 1866. As historian Margaret Alington observes, the sexton was given that title but performed both sexton and verger’s roles, being caretaker of both cemetery and church. During the period of reorganisation into separate cemeteries, the Church of England sexton looked after the whole cemetery until the public cemetery trustees appointed their own sexton in 1857.
Sexton’s Cottage
The first Church of England cemetery sexton, Harry Buxton, who held the position from 1840 to 1847, and his replacement James Futter both lived in private dwellings. During Futter’s tenure, in 1857, the trustees decided to build a sexton’s cottage.
A triangular piece of land on Bolton Street (part of town section 473), adjoining the cemetery but not on the cemetery reserve was purchased from Robert Park, a surveyor, for £25. Work began in 1857 on the cottage, which was built by C. Mills, assisted by the soldiers of the 65th regiment, with the permission of Colonel Gold. Dr Marshall, also of the 65th, contributed towards the costs with a debenture of £122.
As Futter had his own house in Hobson Street the first occupants of Sexton’s Cottage were probably Edward Jupp, then schoolmaster of St Paul’s School, and his family. As he was on site, he also had a cemetery key and kept the register of graves. The Jupps were followed by a labourer, R. Watson who lived there until the end of 1865, when Thomas Madeley, Futter’s replacement, took up residence. He was the first sexton to occupy the cottage.
Madeley resigned in March 1874 and Thomas Carr took over his duties and the residence on 1 April 1874. He also had church duties. Mrs Carr earned extra by washing clergy surplices – she complained about the winter rains making the house very damp. William Mowbray, schoolmaster and organist at St Paul’s, owned the land next to the cottage and around 1875 he developed Mowbray Street. As a result of a re-survey at this time, the Sexton’s Cottage was found to have encroached on Mowbray’s land and so the trustees acquired the necessary small strip of land. In 1885 another room was added to the cottage, which modified the original symmetry of the small cottage. Carr received a £30 grant ‘towards’ the expense of this. This room stands out as an addition, there having been little attempt to integrate it with the existing cottage; but the narrow triangular site (and budget) probably restricted the options available.
In 1891 the cemetery had reached capacity, and the government issued a closing order which disallowed new burial plots in all parts of the cemetery; after that new burials were only allowed in pre-purchased or existing family plots. Many of Wellington’s pioneer European settlers, and some Maori, were buried in the cemetery. For example, members of the Wakefield family connected with the New Zealand Company, and former premier Richard Seddon is buried and has a memorial at the Kelburn end of the cemetery.
The Wellington City Corporation took over control of the Church of England cemetery in February 1892 and incorporated it into the public cemetery, whose sexton became responsible for the whole cemetery. Thomas Carr, whose performance as he became older attracted criticism, stayed on in his capacity as the St Paul’s verger until July 1893. He was still listed as the occupant of the cottage the following year, but by 1895 he had relinquished his tenancy. Surprisingly, the cottage does not appear on the 1892 Thomas Ward Survey Map of Wellington city – the five houses next to it down to Mowbray Street are shown on this map. The public cemetery sexton’s cottage is also not shown on this map, so both may have been excluded as by this time the City controlled the whole cemetery. However, when the map was revised a few years later, Sexton’s Cottage was included.
From 1895 until 1920 the cottage, still owned by the church, was rented out to a succession of tenants, among them Samuel Telfer, a greaser, Robert Allen, a bootmaker, and Miss Eugenie Godet, whose occupation is not known. In 1920 the Diocesan Board of Trustees sold the cottage to Mary West, widow of the Rev. Dr West, a longstanding minister of the Terrace Congregational Church (where the Reserve Bank now stands). The Wests had lived one door down in Bolton Street for many years. It seems Mrs West continued to live at no. 24 and rent out the cottage. In 1927 it was sold to Robert Spittal, a Wellington builder; in 1931 to Jessie James, ‘spinster’; and in 1949 to Ellen Ward, another spinster. However, prior to Ellen Ward, it seems the owners did not usually occupy it. Annie Dudley lived in the cottage from 1924 until 1937, according to street directories. The next occupant, Herbert Hynson, carpenter, took up residence some time prior to 1939. E. Ward was the occupant in 1955.
In 1968 the land was taken for the proposed urban motorway construction. The motorway cut through the cemetery dividing it in two. Many headstones were moved and 3700 burials were reinterred in a mass grave near Sexton’s Cottage. . However, the cottage occupied land that was not required directly for the motorway and so was spared demolition. It was during this period that historian Margaret Alington discovered that the cottage was the former Sexton’s Cottage. The Ministry of Works and Development (MoWD) decided to keep the cottage and restore it. Plans were drawn up in 1976 by Chris Cochran, then working in MoWD’s head office, and work was supervised by architect Sarah Treadwell in the department’s Wellington District Office.
The restoration involved the reinstatement of a considerable amount of fabric. New doors and fireplace surrounds were secured from demolition yards to replace missing joinery. The house was repiled and relined. A photograph from the early 1970s shows the front door had been enclosed in a closed entry porch; this was removed and replaced with an open porch with a gabled roof. The cottage was reopened in 1978 and handed over to the Wellington City Council. A cemetery caretaker was installed in the house for a time. In 1980 the Bolton St Memorial Park was gazetted as a Reserve under the Reserves Act of 1977 and the Sexton’s Cottage and land were incorporated into the Reserve in 1989.
In 2007 the brick path around the building was lowered as it was higher than the bottom boards and prevented ventilation flow under the house. Currently, the cottage is tenanted when possible and also used for an artist-in-residence for between six weeks and three months per year, in collaboration with the Asia New Zealand Foundation.